Cardinal Velasio de Paolis, the Pope's man on the task for helping the Legionaries deal with revelations about its founder, essentially rebuked those who want "vengeance" on the Legion by destroying it. Instead, the pope wants the religious order to remain and to flourish. He asks for prayers that the Legionaries and consecrated in Regnum Christi persevere in their vocations as apostles. EWTN's article below with my comments in blue and emphasis in bold:
If we give the most charitable read possible of another's words, we will always act virtuously.
I would add to the list though, that I have met dozens of Legionaries and I think I can say Yes, every one that I have met is dedicated to Christ through the Church above all, which is manifest by their obedience to it, rather than whatever projects they undertake. My personal experience with the Legionaries has been positive and I hope they continue the great work they have already done by being faithful to Christ and the mission given it by the Church.
Cardinal says efforts aim to 'revitalize' Legion, not harm it
Cardinal Velasio de Paolis, the Pontifical Delegate for the Legionaries of Christ, said the Pope appointed him not to destroy the order but to help promote and encourage new life in it.At a Feb. 27 Mass - celebrated on in the Mexican city of Leon for some 10,000 students who attend Legionary schools in the country - the cardinal noted that his "presence here is an expression of trust on the part of the Holy Father."
He said the Pope appointed him delegate "because he trusts in the Legion and the Regnum Christi Movement. And he pointed his Delegate not to destroy but to revitalize, discover and renew the great vigor that exists in the Legion and the Regnum Christi Movement."
The cardinal said his mission was not to encourage members of the Legion and its lay movement Regnum Christi to "change vocations," but to remain in the two religious bodies. [Cardinal Ratzinger (now Pope Benedict) worked in the CDF during the investigation in the 1980's, I don't think anyone is more informed then he, except perhaps the Cardianl delegate who has visited with every member and house of formation of the order since the beginning of the visitation.]
"The Pope has trust," he continued. "He has trust in man's ability. He has trust, above all, in grace. [Reference here to an unofficial version of gratia supplex?] As Christians, we can see the future with great hope because we believe in God's kindness, which continually renews and restores our hearts and makes us able to carry out our work in ever more grand and beautiful ways."
Despite our weaknesses, the cardinal added, grace "allows us to persevere and not to be scandalized even by sin because the grace of the Lord is greater than our misery, than our weaknesses and even our sin."
Cardinal de Paolis said the future belongs to those who trust and commit themselves to living and persevering in their own vocations.
I have met too many people who don't like the Legion because of what they have heard rather than actually experienced. Yes, the order grew fast (and continues to). Yes, there have been issues of overly strict policy and confidentiality (which the pope moved to abolish a few years ago).Yes, they maintain many priniples that are not popular today even in mainstream Catholicism. Yes, the founder had fallen into serious sin. But to say that the order as a whole must also be corrupt or even defective, without any experience other than gossip or without any attempt to understand the reasons why they do things the way they do, is off base. As we find is the purpose of the blog, when you find yourself in a potential disagreement with someone, you must first try to understand their position and then square yours up against it. As Aquinas paraphrases, strengthen the argument of an opponent if it was not presented well,"Let us pray that all of us will persevere in our Christian vocations; for the Legionaries, that they persevere in their vocations; for the consecrated souls of the Regnum Christi Movement; and for all the faithful committed to spreading (the faith), to devoting their efforts to getting others to know and love the Lord." [Indeed.]
If we give the most charitable read possible of another's words, we will always act virtuously.
I would add to the list though, that I have met dozens of Legionaries and I think I can say Yes, every one that I have met is dedicated to Christ through the Church above all, which is manifest by their obedience to it, rather than whatever projects they undertake. My personal experience with the Legionaries has been positive and I hope they continue the great work they have already done by being faithful to Christ and the mission given it by the Church.
If you want some examples of projects that would not have been possible without them in the United States let's list a few:
- Zenit
- The National Catholic Register (Now owned by EWTN as of 2011)
- Institute of Psychological Sciences in D.C.
- Catholic.net
- Familia
- Mission Youth
- PureFashion
Lesser Known


Comments are open again for those who have an opinion about the comment of the Cardinal delegate. I do not wish to discuss the Legion in general here. Thank you for your understanding.
ReplyDelete"Despite our weaknesses, the cardinal added, grace "allows us to persevere and not to be scandalized even by sin because the grace of the Lord is greater than our misery, than our weaknesses and even our sin." "
ReplyDeleteIf all the scandals of late have not reinforced our trust in God's greatness, I don't know what will. I know that but for his grace I would be a complete mess. Prayers for all the cardinal has to undertake from here on out.
Familia was not started by RC/LC. It began with a common Catholic couple. LC/RC shmoozed them and convinced them to sign off rights to the Familia name. Shame on LC.
ReplyDeleteI'm not sure if that's actually true or not...but if it is, then my listing of it was meant to give credit to the part they have built up. How the ownership and the will of the owner affects the quality of the apostolate and creates shame is beyond me...try to be a bit more optimistic and less bitter.
DeleteThe Legion is no longer growing with new vocations but only with new ordinations. The vocations that are currently in the pipeline will maintain the ordination numbers near 50 per year for the next few years, but the numbers coming into their pipeline, ie, new seminarians, has dropped off considerably. Notice the Cardinal doesn´t say anything about new growth, but what is inside the Legion now - their own personal growth and for them to stay where they are at. Also there are no longer any vocations coming into their seminary in Europe except for a few pockets. Their numbers are essentially the US, Mexico and Brazil. I think that the huge dropoff in incoming vocations would be a huge concern for the Cardinal but he actually mentions it. This tells me that while not discouraging the vocational efforts externally, he may not be so convinced that this is a good time for the Legion to grow, but rather to consolidate itself. Also encouraging new life in the Legion also presumes that something is weak or even dying. If the Legion was strong internally these words would actually be kind of offensive. While not advocating the total destruction of the Legion (why would he sign on and then criticize his mission ? wouldn´t make any sense), he doesn´t state that it is healthy but only that the people inside are relatively healthy which is something completely separate. I also see from his words that his commitment to the Legion may be coming to an end within a few years. Why? Well if I was heading up the effort I would first talk about vocations, then about vocations and finally about vocations. He already knows the record of institutions in the Church that stop growing. They tend to stagnate and fail to recover strong growth patterns. So if I was looking at a 10 year window I would be focusing alot on vocations. The Cardinal does not. At this point I think he sees his mission as more short term. He just wants to make sure there is enough glue for this whole thing to stick together until the General Chapter and more than likely he will be pass on his role to the new General Director replacing Fr. Alvaro.
ReplyDelete